February 25, 2026

Should Your 401(k) Plan Adopt An Auto-Enrollment Feature?

Brian Davis

Secure Act 2.0 requires employers to start automatically enrolling employees for tax-saving 401(k) elective deferral contributions (also called salary reduction contributions) for all new plans. Exceptions apply for plans established prior to December 29, 2022, new businesses in operation for less than 3 years,  and small businesses with10 or fewer employees.

The end result of these changes: Companies with auto-enrollment features will have more employees participating. Larger allowable salary reduction contributions can likely be made for higher-paid employees, because lower-paid workers will be contributing more.

That is because the Internal Revenue Code prohibits plans from discriminating in favor of highly compensated employees with respect to contributions or benefits.

Plans are tested for discrimination using a mathematical formula that measures contributions for highly compensated employees with those of other employees.

Rule Changes

The tax law includes two other important auto-enrollment rules:

1. A Window Period to Recover Unintended Contributions. The first change allows 401(k) plans to give employees a window period of up to 90 days after the auto-enrollment date to opt out of the program and get their money back. Of course, the amounts employees get back will be added back to their taxable wages.

2. A Safe-Harbor Auto-Enrollment Contribution Formula. This encourages employers to install so-called safe-harbor automatic enrollment arrangements. These have escalating contribution percentages. For example, a plan with a safe-harbor feature could automatically withhold at least three percent of an employee’s salary for the first year, increasing to at least four percent for the second year, going up again to at least five percent for the third year, and then increasing to at least six percent for later years. (The percentage cannot exceed 10% for any year.)

The employer is required to match a portion of each employee’s auto‑enrollment contributions (according to another formula), and those employer matching contributions must be 100% vested after two years.

An Example of the Rules in Action

Let’s say your company’s 401(k) plan installs an auto‑enrollment arrangement with escalating safe-harbor contribution percentages.

An employee named Ben doesn’t opt out of the program. Let’s assume:

  • Ben’s salary is $50,000. For this year, 3% of his salary (or $1,500) will automatically be withheld and contributed to his 401(k) account.
  • For next year, Ben’s salary is $53,000 and 4% (or $2,120) will automatically be contributed.
  • Ben’s salary increases to $58,000 in the following year. For that year, 5% will automatically go into his account, which amounts to $2,900.
  • The next year, Ben gets another raise and now earns $60,000. For that year, 6% of his salary (or $3,600) is contributed.
  • For later years, the plan calls for the same 6% automatic contribution rate.

The auto‑enrollment feature puts Ben’s retirement savings on cruise control and allows him to put away $10,120 over four years, not including investment earnings. It also lowers his income tax bills.

Meanwhile, it makes it easy for your company to satisfy the nondiscrimination and top heavy rules that can otherwise make a 401(k) plan troublesome to operate.

Key Point: A 401(k) plan that includes a safe-harbor auto-enrollment arrangement is deemed to accomplish the following:

  • It automatically satisfies the complicated nondiscrimination rules for employee elective deferral contributions and employer matching contributions.
  • It also fulfills the equally complex “top heavy” contribution rules, which measure the account values of “key employees” as compared with other employees in the plan. Therefore, a beneficial side effect of installing a safe-harbor auto-enrollment feature is that higher-paid employees can start making larger elective deferral contributions without causing the plan to violate the nondiscrimination and top heavy rules.

There are many advantages for employers in the new 401(k) plan auto-enrollment rules, which can be applied to new hires or all qualified employees.

©  2025

Hobe & Lucas Certified Public Accountants, Inc. is a full-service accounting and business consulting firm dedicated to providing clients with exceptional value.

Upload 8879 Make A Payment

Contact Info

6000 Freedom Square Dr #550

Independence, OH 44131

216-524-8900 info@hobe.com

Advisory Services offered through Avantax Planning Partners, Inc., a registered investment adviser. Securities may be offered through Cetera Wealth Services, LLC, member FINRA/SIPC. Additional advisory services may be offered through Cetera Investment Advisers LLC. Cetera named entities and Avantax Planning Partners, Inc. are affiliated. 3390 Asbury Rd, Dubuque, IA 52002. 563-582-2855.

Check your Financial Professionals registration status on https://brokercheck.finra.org/ and/or https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/.

Cetera named entities and Avantax Planning Partners, Inc. are independent of and unrelated to Hobe & Lucas Certified Public Accountants, Inc.